Liquid eyeliner, please recommend a decent one!

[BillieGi]

I do prefer the pen types rather than the dip ones but at this point i will try any.

Not clumpy, dark coverage, easy to 'flick at corners' and ling lasting and NOT smudgy!

I recently got the Lisa Eldridge one and really love it, it is a bit expensive though. Its a very true black, lasts really well and I've had no issues with smudging. I wear contact lenses and find my eyes can water quite a lot and never had an issue with this

I have the Diorshow On Stage Liner by Dior. I have been very impressed. I use it to tightline my upper lashes and it doesn’t come off or give me panda eyes.

Loreal - doesn't smudge, easy to apply, affordable. Tried more expensive ones but keep coming back to it.

I have tried most of them. Rimmel all the way for me (it's liquid though and not a felt tip pen). It's the only one that stays on (with primer).

KVD tattoo liner is the BEST I’ve used. Look no further. Thank me later. (Kat Von D)

edited to add: it’s a gel pen liner

Im very ham fisted but I manage to get a perfect line with Barry M dip eyeliner everytime even though I make a mess with the pen ones. It just seems to have the perfect brush.