Thanks for the suggestions.
the mohair one would be too deep a v on me as I’m so short, and I have strong memories of my mum spending six months knitting me a green mohair jumper in the 1990s that I then had to wear loads to justify the time and cost of the wool, so I don’t think mohair is for me!
the green heavy knit one is the type I’ve had in the past and is heavier than what I had in mind.
I’m searching for the holy grail, clearly