Birkenstocks!

[Itsrainingten]

I need to replace my trusty black leather Arizona's. What should I get? I want a pair that work with casual dresses and trousers so I think Arizona is probably best (I don't like the toe post ones) although I quite like the Zurich.
And is oiled leather or suede better? I'm thinking suede more comfortable and leather longer lasting. Any thoughts?

Leather, my lovely pink suede ones got so dirty quickly. The toe post ones are surprisingly comfortable and I love the way they look.

Ah yeah I hadn't thought about them getting dirty. Thanks. No I can't do the toe post. They kill my feet for some reason

Sorry I meant the Mayari ones. I have those and Arizonas. Go Arizona, can't go wrong, the pink suede are gorgeous but they did get dirty. Darker suede might be ok, they are super comfortable