I was given a Trish McEvoy mascara. It makes little tubes around the lashes which set and don’t smudge at all. You wash off with water and the mascara stays as tubes so you just rinse off all these spiders legs, with zero smudging and no need for make up remover. Does any one use something similar but less expensive? I like the way it looks too: lots of fine lashes, not clumpy at all but mist of all I love not having to cleanse lots around my eyes.