It's great when you finally find the products that work for you, isn't it?
I recently discovered that NARS Deauville is exactly the right shade for me ( MAC would be NC15 probably, so around the same shade as you but different undertone), and that's been a game changer.
I've concentrated much more on skincare in the past couple of years, so I don't need to worry about having a dense looking base as my skin is now pretty good -most days I don't bother with foundation at all, just concealer round my nose, chin and any blotchy bits, a dab of powder, eyebrows, bronzer and lipstick.
So at the moment my perfect make up bag looks like this:
( if going all out):
Charlotte Tilbury Flawless Filter in Medium
Nars Light Reflecting foundation
Collection concealer ( the NARS creamy concealer dupe)
Powder along T zone, currently using a CT one which I'm not fussed about but need to use up.
Bronzer - Normally Hoola but have been using a Revolution one which is pretty good
Stila convertible colour in Camellia for blush
Mascara - currently working my way through a load of drugstore ones but will probably go back to Lancôme Hypnose like I always do
ByTerry Ombré blackstar Bronze Moon to scribble on an eye
Max Factor Brow Revival (cheaper than Boy Brow and just as good)
Lipsticks- I go with the flow, depending if I fancy bright or not. Currently enjoying Revolutions 'Ruby'and 'Heart Race'