Keep or return

[doingmyboxin]

Received a few things for holiday today. Definitely retiring one dress and one top, but undecided on two other dresses.

Can you tell me what you think?

I'm not sure that puff sleeves suit me on the spotty dress, and I'm just more sure about the coloured one overall.

Obviously the spotty dress needs ironed!

Thank you!

Love the coloured one

I think the white one makes you too top heavy but the second one is lovely, it give you a lovely silhouette and shows you shape, very pretty

The coloured one is great on you. Keep that one.

I agree, the bright one looks great on you.

Coloured one is lovely

The coloured one really suits you - keep it!

Both a no from me I'm afraid

Keep the coloured one but return the puff sleeves, I say

Agree that the coloured one is good keep it. Send the other back as it looks ill fitting

I like the coloured one too, where did you buy it?

It's from New Look

I like them both, but agree that the 2nd one is more flattering.

The coloured one makes you look 2 sizes smaller than the other one

The 2nd dress looks far better on you, I think.

The spotty one is not nearly so flattering, and also it's so thin that your underwear is fairly visible through it...

I like the coloured one on you. The spotty one just looks washed out and I think it's the big buttons that are putting me off it too.

I vote keep the coloured one, return the other one. There's something about the sleeves, or the way they are attached, that doesn't look quite right.

Put a belt with the spotty dress because it doesn't have much shape but the sleeves are lovely.
The colourful one looks really nice.

I don't like either because they both widen your shoulder and it messes with your proportions but the colourful one with ruffle sleeves is better than the white puffed one. I think shorter dress mid thigh or longer dress to mid calf would look better.

I'd keep the second one, but not the first one. I don't think the sleeves are great and it looks a wee bit fast fashiony to me...the second one is more classic and won't date I don't think

Okay, looks like will be keeping one out of four then.

Good news for my bank account at least

Yep, defo the coloured one!

I’d send the first one back as the sleeves and neckline don’t do anything for you.

I suggest you return the first dress. The second is more flattering.

The second one is a good shape, but I think that pattern is more like a work dress, rather than a holiday. Also, those frills on the sleeves; what purpose do they serve?

Do you have a link to the coloured one? It's lovely!