Soft pencil eye liners

[JinglingHellsBells]

Your best buys?

I've used Clinique and Bobbi Brown for years - the twisty up eye liners - but the point always goes too thick (and I like a fine line under my eye- maybe that's old fashioned now?)

Any ideas or just stop lining my lower lid :)

Beautypie

Is Beautypie a brand or a subscription? Never heard of it. Or seen it in shops.