I'm honestly useless at eyeliner. I like how it looks but I always get it all over my eyelashes and smear it over my lids. I'm better at applying it to my waterline, however my current choices are my posh Mac liquid one where the little brush is really fine and bendy, so smears everywhere (but stays in place) or my cheap Aldi retractable pencil that is super easy to apply to my waterline, but smudges within 30 seconds.
I thought a pen might be a good compromise, because the nib is quite sturdy. But they always dry out after about two weeks!
Can anyone recommend something an idiot like me can use?