Pencil eyeliner, waterproof, smudgeproof, longlasting

[DelphiniumBlue]

Can anyone recommend a decent pencil eyeliner which stays put?
I've used the Nars one for a few years but it doesn't seem to be in stock anywhere in any shade of mid-dark brown.
I've got the Bobbi Brown one, and the Infallible one and I end up with panda eyes within an hour or so. The Nars one stays put, but I've almost run out and am now beginning to panic - can anyone help?

Laura mercier does not budge

L'Oréal Le Liner

I can’t find a good one either. I don’t want liquid but not a pencil either.

I swear by fenty

fentybeauty.com/products/flypencil-longwear-pencil-eyeliner-cuz-im-black

Various colours

Avon glimmersticks are pretty good.

avon glimmersticks go for darker shades , rich ,intense colour lasts ages i have never found a better one.
usually good offer on them too .

Thanks, are the Fenty ones available in shops or just online?
The Avon ones are reasonably priced, and the Laura Mercier one looks to be well reviewed. I just want one that doesn't slide down my face after 10 minutes outside!

Hi the fenty ones are available at boots in the larger stores

il0vew1ne* thank you.

Rodial. Black or Brown.

Doesn't budge on my greasy eyelids.

@halfsiesonapotnoodle

Avon glimmersticks are pretty good.

They certainly are. They beat every expensive brand.

Charlotte Tilbury rock n kohl in barbarella brown is my absolute go to

I was coming on to say NARS! So as a replacement, I'd second (third!) Avon Glimmersticks.