Waterproof or tubing mascara

[Gonnagetgoing]

Most normal mascaras smudge on me these days so recently bought:-

• Glossier tubing mascara - doesn't give me the definition I need but nice, looks more 'natural' on me!
• Dior Waterproof mascara - great, good definition - nice colour but smudged once last week!

Ideally I'd love a great waterproof or tubing mascara budget prices or pay more but give the definition that I prefer as I have fairly short lashes otherwise.

Anyone seen anything?

I use L’Oréal beauty tubes. Has a conditioning serum amd tuning mascara. It’s really good and from Amazon only £8

Another vote for Clinique lash power

I bought a Shisheido one cheaply at TK MAXX and it is excellent. Big impact, neither crumbles nor smudges.

This is all really helpful. I have long, but very straight lashes, together with oily lids.
I recently started using a maybelline water proof mascara, that is great for holding a curl - I look half a sleep without them curled up. The only problem being is that it does smudge.
Would a tubing mascara hold the curl in like a waterproof one does?

Clinique Lash Power
Victoria Beckham Future Lash

These are both amazing - Clinique's is available in brown as well as black, which is great for daytime - I've been using it in brown and black for years. I bought VB's more recently, it only comes in black but the wand is longer and the brush is nicer to apply.

@NameChangeinHaste
Try Clinique high impact curling mascara if you haven't already.

Though I personally wear lash power more as it's a bit more definition