Best non-liquid, self-sharpening eyeliner

[Pigtailsandall]

I just cannot get on with liquid eyeliner but I'd love to get a self-sharpening one which is actually precise. I've had a Clinique one for the last year; it's ok but you do have press it quite hard sometimes. Are there any amazing ones on the market which I've missed? What's your favourite eyeliner?

Watching wirh interest.
I don't like liquid eyeliner either
I'm after a really soft kohl pencil that doesn't dry out, one that's good for tight lining.

I like the Rimmel London Exaggerate Waterproof Eye Definer - it's quite precise but has a smudger to soften it. And it's a pop up so no sharpening.

Absolutely hands down the Chanel Stylo Yeaux waterproof eyeliner pencils.
They come in loads of colours, can be used on the waterline, are so easy to apply and do not budge once applied. They also have a sharpener hidden at the end of the pencil.

I have at least half a dozen colours.

Sorry I forgot to add - the Chanel ones are the kind that wind up, but you can sharpen them if you want to get a finer point on them.

I love Avon glimmersticks, especially for tightlining.