Nice smudgy eyeliner recommendations

[TiggyTips]

I'm 48, very nearly 49 and as much as I'd like to go with the winged eyeliner look, I can't perfect it and I think, on me, it looks a bit to try hard if I can actually get it to look ok. I need a nice dark brown, eye liner that smudges a bit, but also lasts well and doesn't melt into my skin. Happy to pay a bit to get a good one!

www.urbandecay.co.uk/en_GB/eyes/eyeliner/24-7/122.html?gclsrc=aw.ds&&gclid=Cj0KCQjw4ImEBhDFARIsAGOTMj98I311h0aplmHFPuqGZs9wn5_nlQ_TzboDyKzwuf262Dfc2mgNlXgaApRUEALw_wcB

I like the Bobbi Brown kajal pencil in black coffee.

Victoria Beckham satin kajal liner in cocoa.

Her eyeliners are fantastic. Soft and smudgy. Definitely recommend

It gets bad reviews online but I love the lord and Berry smudge proof eyeliner.

Urban decay eyeliners are great too bit you have to work quickly before they set.

Avon glimmer sticks work well for me. They twist up so aren’t sharp. I do a rough line then smudge it with a wee blending brush. It lasts pretty well, especially if I use a primer.