Anyone rate Nars mascaras?

[Tinks15]

Currently using a Clinique one which i do quite like, however I’m a big fan of Nars so was thinking of trying theirs...does anyone recommend the mascaras?

My eyelashes are ridiculously short & straight so need something decent.

This is going to be such a weird answer.
No, I use the orgasm one. However, I've recently had my lashes LVLd and since the mascara now works amazingly.

The fall out used to be a problem but now it doesn't.

Such a not helpful comment really.

I love everything Nars- all my other make up is Nars. I got the mascara and I’m really disappointed. It’s really not great. Very clumpy, not very lengthening. All in all I def wouldn’t buy again. When it’s done I’m going to go back to the Charlotte Tilbury one I had before.

Maybe I won’t bother then & i’ll just stick to the Clinique one I like, not sure on any other decent ones.

I got a sample size of the ( Climax? I hate their fecking names!) and it is very Meh.

I don't know why I do it - I spend a fortune on cheaper mascaras only to go back to Lancôme Hypnose every time.

I love Nars and have a whole drawer full of their products but none of their mascaras have wowed me.

I got the By Terry Lash Expert Twist Brush mascara recently after reading rave reviews, and it's my favourite so far (massive beauty junkie here so have tried a lot!). You can twist the brush to adjust to from lengthening to volume. I mainly use the lengthening setting but just love the formula.

I got a sample of the Climax one. Wore it once and it smudged all round my eyes and that was in the house (not in the rain or wearing a mask). Got the new Hourglass one, that's pretty decent. The Clinique Chubby one I've found to be pretty good recently.

I don’t like the nars one I have. Hard to beat lancome for mascara.

I got a sample of the Climax one. It went on alright. Seemed ok but as it is not waterproof, is no good for me!