Looking for a black eyeliner that twists open

[LifeInAHamsterWheel]

I need a new eyeliner, I like it to be very pigmented and have staying power. I use it for tightlining if that makes any difference. I've just used the very end of a Pixi one which was brilliant. BUT I have a problem with my hand and I'd rather not have to sharpen a pencil so am hoping somone can recommend a really good black eyeliner that you twist up instead?

There are the ones that are a brush that you dip in gel - Rimmel do one - but you need a steady hand.
Most of the pencil ones like Stay Perfect don't twist or sharpen, and I don't get on with them, but I think that Rimmel, Maybelline or Essence do them. Have a look in Superdrug.

The felt tip ones by Collection are pretty good.

Correction, I think that Rimmel, Maybelline or Essence do the ones that you twist up.

Soap and glory

I buy this Japanese one when I'm in the Far East. I use it for tight lining too and it doesn't budge or give me panda eyes.

Chanel waterproof one is great and it twists up with a wee sharpener in the end

Thanks for suggestions. I am currently using a Catrice one but the staying power is crap.

I have yet to find a liner for tightlineing that stays put, it always transfers to bottom lid, and as for lining the water line forget it, nothing i use stays put. I few I have tried, pixi, double wear, loreal, maybelline, no7, laura geller, laura mercier, nyx, can anyone recommend a liner for the water line.

www.kikocosmetics.com/en-gb/make-up/eyes/eye-pencils/Deep-Black-Kajal/p-KM0030301200144

The normal Kajal for waterline is excellent too

www.superdrug.com/Make-Up/Eye-Makeup/Eyeliner/Rimmel-Ultimate-Kohl-Eye-Pencil-Kajal-Black-Obsidian/p/755550?gclid=CjwKCAiAiML-BRAAEiwAuWVggvrgerzzA74SYlhkkJPYjJ4IawYNLW96FRGrwy85HXWWe9GkRExkNxoCA10QAvD_BwE&gclsrc=aw.ds

This one twists but it is a kajal eyeliner so slighter thicker. I put it in my waterline and then smudge it out.

I love the felt tip Collection one . It never budges and is so easy to use . Plus it's only £3

The rimmel one is excellent

Avon blackest black glimmerstick eyeliner. They have a multitude of twist up different coloured eyeliners

@1vandal2 was just about to say the same 😆

The glimmer sticks are excellent and last all day. I have one in black, a glittery gunmetal grey, purple and dark green.

Last year I saw them at quite a few local Christmas fairs for £1

I use the Benefit Bad Gal Bang 24 hour one for tightlining. Excellent staying power and is twist up so no sharpening.
www.johnlewis.com/benefit-badgal-bang-24-hour-eye-pencil/p4281437?s_ppc=1dxDSA-BEAUTY39700018921587155&tmad=c&tmcampid=1&gclid=EAIaIQobChMIxZmAsaPF7QIVjt_tCh04yw4PEAAYASAAEgJ4QfD_BwE&gclsrc=aw.ds

Stila twists and I find it great for not budging

Rimmel, Revlon & L’Oreal do one. Not just black either.

Bobbi Brown, really good staying power

I have a couple, one is Ester Lauder, the other I can't remember the brand but it was cheaper from Amazon

Avon do them. I went mad and bought them in every colour! They're great.

This Milk eyeliner fits the bill, I wear it every day: www.cultbeauty.co.uk/milk-makeup-long-wear-gel-eyeliner.html

@millymoo1202

Chanel waterproof one is great and it twists up with a wee sharpener in the end

Second this!

The Essence ones from Wilko are super cheap and really good!

I agree with PPs - the Avon glimmersticks are great! Really easy to twist and apply, they stay on all day and ridiculously cheap!

Hourglass gel liner pen. It’s the darkest black and super slim, twists up and is always sharp. I use it for tightlining

Yeah i have at least one of each colour