Barbour Boots- which pair?

[ShouldHaveCouldHaveWouldHave]

Please help me decide which boots to buy!
I really want some black, leather boots I can wear with tights and dresses/jumper dresses for work through the winter and haven’t seen any I like more than Barbour ones.
So the Rimini or Abigail?

I prefer the Abigail, I find a slightly wider ankle more flattering than a narrow ankle when teamed with dresses/skirts. Both very similar though. Both should look good!

Number 2

I think Rimini will look better with dresses /tights

@thirstyformore Good point, I didn’t even see the difference in ankle size.
I think the brown sole is the thing that’s not winning me over with the Abigail even though I love the overall look and I prefer the lower heel of them than Rimini.
I need a make a decision before the Rimini goes back up in price or they sell out.
Maybe I’m going to have to bite the bullet, order both and try them on!

2

Based on the pics, I much prefer the Abigail. But personally, I'd get both and try on.

I have the Rimini boots and absolutely love them but haven't been able to get them to look right with my dresses and skirts.