If you had to pick one of these three rings

[Nimbybimbo]

Which would it be??

What a mixture of responses
The rings are all 9ct gold; the white gold at the bottom is an aquamarine, rose gold in the middle is garnet and the yellow gold at the top is a stone called sphene. It's my favourite but it's a very soft stone and not suitable for wearing everyday. That would be ok though, as it's just a little treat to be worn every now and again, not an engagement ring or anything

The top one

Bottom
then middle.

Bottom, then top. I really love the mixture of responses, I think that just goes to show how each persons taste varies so much!

This thread is like watching Strike It Lucky. Top middle or bottom?

I vote bottom. Not a fan of yellow stones and I'm not sure the middle stone (is that really a garnet? It looks purple on my monitor) suits the rose gold setting.

Have you looked at tanzanite though @Nimbybimbo ? My engagement ring is tanzanite and it’s so pretty, you can get them from quite a deep almost amethyst purple to a pale lilac/blue similar to aquamarine

@TheGirlWhoLived

Have you looked at tanzanite though *@Nimbybimbo* ? My engagement ring is tanzanite and it’s so pretty, you can get them from quite a deep almost amethyst purple to a pale lilac/blue similar to aquamarine

Tanzanite is quite a soft stone and not really recommended for everyday wear. Be careful with it, I scratched mine wearing it just for best in the evenings.

Top

Bottom

Yeah @Plonque I got married and wear a diamond wedding band now so my tanzanite just looks at me forlornly on the dresser

middle

Middle but If it's an engagement ring, I'm not sure how it would sit with a wedding ring.

If the bottom is an aquamarine, they look lovely when clean but can look like a dirty diamond.

I like the shape of the top one but am not a fan of yellow gold. The bottom one is pretty but aquamarine can seem washed out. I don’t like the middle one very much-it’s a bit chunky for me.

Aquamarine one