Black (puffer) winter coat

[goingtogetthekids]

I'm struggling to find a black long puffer coat for winter that I really like.
Right now i have bought this:

www.outdoorandcountry.co.uk/womens-barbour-international-lineout-quilted-jacket.html

And this:

www.superdry.com/womens/jackets

And really can't decide which one i like or do I really like either.
The first one looks better zipped up and belted and the second one looks much better unzipped (but obviously can't wear like this in the middle of winter).

Anyone have any other suggestions in similar price range?

Well, ive actually changed my mind now and decided to keep the Barbour one. It's much more flattering zipped up with the belt and just feels more 'me' (I'm not an old lady yet!) the superdry one looks good unzipped but realistically that's not how i will usually wear it, zipped up it just looks plain, but it does seem warmer.
Anyway if I change my mind again then I won't come back to announce it as it's getting a bit silly now being so indecisive

I got the short version of this last year & I absolutely love it 🥰
www.marksandspencer.com/comfort-stretch-padded-coat/p/clp60272527?color=BLACK

@goingtoraintoday it's not silly at all, you are investing in a coat and want it to be perfect so don't worry. Hope one of them does work for you.