Best liner for waterline/tightlining

[AhFiddledeedee]

No matter what pencil I get, I inevitably seem to get smudges under my eyes.

So many times I've been in the work bathroom trying to clean up under my eyes and people ask if I'm ok (they think I'm crying rubbing tissue under my eyes!)

I'd heard good things about Stila Kadal pencil for being budget proof. But it's the same story.

I've tried so many brands, those that claim to be waterproof and budgeproof.

I get on generally ok with liquid liner, but I like the effect of tightlining with a pencil, but it just looks so crap after a few hours.

Help!

*budge proof not budget proof!

You need the Laura Mercier Cake Tight Liner. Apply with a fine brush, really working it into the base of your upper lashes, from underneath. Try not to blink for as long as you can while it sets, and it doesn't budge all day.

I have tried just about every pencil I can think of and they all smudge, I think it is my oily eyelids. I've had most success with Laura Mercier Cake tightener as above, I apply using a flat liner brush. But I have to make sure I get the consistency right.

I have also used just a dark eyeshadow, "scrubbed" into the base of my lashes, which gives a softer look. If I'm in a rush I sometimes use tubing mascara on a flat liner brush as tightener as my eyes are watery as well as being oily.

I just use a dark eyeshadow and a brush like the Mac 212.
LM cake liner is okay, but I only use it as a traditional eyeliner, rather than tightlining.

Most eyeliners smudge on me. This one has been good for both tightlining and as traditional eyeliner though: www.superdrug.com/Make-Up/Eye-Makeup/Eyeliner/Maybelline-Lasting-Drama-Gel-Eyeliner-01-Black/p/249975

Trish McEvoy gel eyeliner in Deep Aubergine 👌

I like the retractable ones, revlon do a good skinny one, also catrice ones are also good.

I like this one www.cultbeauty.co.uk/milk-makeup-long-wear-gel-eyeliner.html

The Chanel waterproof eyeliner pencils are great. The Trish McEvoy ones mentioned are also excellent although don't come in as many colours. The Laura Mercier tightline ones smudge on me, I have more than one colour but they all smudge. (I do have oily skin though)

Marc Jacobs highliner lasts great on me

I had high hopes for the marc jacobs highliner but it smudged as soon as I touched my eyes

I use this Stila Stay All Day eyeliner, which comes in a pen. I'm not sure its designed for tightlining, but it doesn't budge!

Double wear black eyeliner

Thank you for your responses everyone. I've got a few to try out now. Just have to tell myself to use up what I have before buying more!!