Best eyebrow pencil / shadow that isn't too reddish

[MarioPuzo]

My eyebrows are naturally very pale (also patchy thanks to some overzealous plucking in the 90s) so to avoid looking like an egg, I have to colour them in with a pencil or shadow. I used to have them tinted regularly but that's not possible now.

I've tried a few different products in medium / dark brown colours, but all the ones I've tried seem to have very reddish undertones that don't look natural on me. Obviously I don't want permanent marker black brows but want eyebrows that look natural and not like clown make up. 🤡

Does anybody know of a good eyebrow product that has a darker undertone?

HD do an eyebrow pallet. It comes in a few shades so you can get a colour for your skin tone. (:

Hourglass in the shade “ash”

Kiko are very good.

Second Kiko

I was using Kiko but switched to this
www.superdrug.com/Make-Up/Eye-Makeup/Eyebrows/Eyebrow-Pencils/MUA-Brow-Define-Micro-Eyebrow-Pencil-Fair-006/p/772890

Thank you! Please all have a slice of cake

I'd never even heard of Kiko. I might start on the cheap ones (Superdrug and Kiko) then work my way up to HD and Hourglass if the first ones are no good. I just want eyebrows, is that so much to ask?

tint them yourself! So easy and pretty much foolproof. Boots/Superdrug have kits

Wooden colouring pencil in black or brown just make sure the end is not too sharp.

Benefit Goof Proof in shade 1, taupe