Dupe for Benefit Benebalm?

[seekingwaxwings]

I loved Benebalm but Benefit have finally discontinued it. I like how it's subtle, moisturising and a lovely rosy translucent colour. Has anyone found a product that matches up in colour and texture? I prefer a stick type balm to fiddly tins. Thanks!

I miss benebalm 😭 I’ve found this to be a good (and cheap!) replacement though.

Didn’t attach!

Argh, I give up 😂

Like you OP I was pretty devastated when Benebalm was discontinued. I Went on a bit of a mission, and had a few failures before discovering Origins Blooming Sheer in Totally Tulip. This is a really good dupe.
Second best is L’Oréal Colour Richie Shine in Watermelon Plump.
Hope this helps. I hate it when things you love and buy regularly are discontinued.

It's ok I can see the photo!

Thanks for replying, which shade is most like Benebalm (which I think came in just one colour)?

Oops cross posted, thank you too greenteaandchives. Looks like I have a couple of possible replacements to try!

I have never got on with other lipstick, I always felt faintly ridiculous in them and the colours never suit me ; Benebalm was like an improvement on my natural lips. I believe that's called MLBB (my lips but better)!

Oh no, I didn’t realise they’d been discontinued! I love the red one for low effort red lips.

Oh has it been discontinued!? Maybe have a look at the tinted lipbalms from Fresh - I haven’t tried them myself but they are very popular. The Icon shade seems a good colour match.

Noooo I didn't know it had been discontinued!!! Argh!!
And the Kiehls one got discontinued ages ago too.
I am going to search out that Origins one, thanks for the tip.

Looks like a new balm is coming out soon to replace the Benebalms. This is from the American website so hopefully should be released here soon

@Miseryisabutterfly could you tell us which shade is most like Benebalm please? Thanks!

Good to hear about the new balms coming out soon but I hope Benefit tell us which (if any) of the shades match Benebalm, because I don't think we're going to be allowed to try out lipstick colours on skin any time soon.

Seems like it was discontinued a while ago as it’s literally out of stock everywhere.

Is Benetint supposed to be the same shade?

I have tried Nars Afterglow lip balms which are a very similar product premise. Haven’t tried benebalm so can’t say which Nars shade is similar, but as they’re all supposed to be sheer products, the end result of the closest shade shouldn’t vary that much

Have a good search on the Internet, there are sites that sell discontinued cosmetic products.

Fresh sugar is a good dupe texture wise - they have a bunch of colours and it’s got SPF. I really love the shade coral.
www.cultbeauty.co.uk/fresh-tinted-lip-treatment-sunscreen-spf-15.html

From what's been said above, this may be of use. I have a discontinued colour which I bagged for a quid in Poundland. www.burtsbees.co.uk/tinted-lip-balm/11678054.html?utm_medium=cpc&utm_source=bing&utm_campaign=FY20_ALL_GBR_BUR_BALM&_UK%20||%20EN%20||%20SEA%20||%20BRAND%20||%20Core%20||%20EM_PUR