Eye pencil

[nopuppiesallowed]

For years I've used No7 Stay Perfect eye pencil in Deep Green, but now Boots seems to have changed the formula and now they're impossible to sharpen. Any suggestions for a long lasting replacement please?

I've got one in black and was disappointed that it couldn't be sharpened too, so am just watching. I think Collection does a green felt tip type long lasting eye-liner but browsing for make up seems a distant memory.

Eye of Horus - Nubian Brown is the best ever

Not quite what you asked but I dragged out the stash of eyeliners yesterday, and put on Benefit Bad Gal eyeliner - a pencil one. The first application had vanished in about 2 hours so I reapplied it and I looked a bit like a panda about 5 hrs later.

The Urban Decay 24/7 liners. Do a search, there was a big thread on them a few months ago and loads of people bought the green one. I bought a taupe one and it's great.