I have a 14 year old Benefit Badgal black eyeliner and it's down to a stub.
I want to replace it but they've long discontinued it. It was a chunky pink pencil and the replacement by one is a thin pencil. Have tried it and not loving it. Bought a few others but I loved that chunky feel to the old Benefit pencil and the soft black eyeliner.
Any suggestions what I can try to replace it with please.