Does such a thing exist, mascara that lengthens without....

[MiniTheMinx]

I'm looking for a mascara that will lengthen without adding volume. Everything I've tried is too thick, clumpy and false looking.

I have very thick lashes and lots of them. So I feel I need something that adds length and definition.

Any recommendations? thank you

You don't comment on budget.
However... with this particular brief Estée Lauder Double Wear. Excellent lengthener but does not substantially volumise.

Budget wise soap and glory thick and fast, no clumping.

Rimmel lash accelerator or benefit roller one.

Primark do a fake lash one in a silver tube that lengthens without adding volume its pretty good

Lancôme definicils

Thank you everyone for the responses.
Fridaysgirl I don't have a budget, I've spent a small fortune already making disastrous buys! I like Estee Lauder so I'll try it because I buy their Perfectionist Pro which is brilliant.

GeePipe I have that actually, it's quite good, but for some reason its making my eyes itch. I like the brush to it, it adds definition.

HarryRug yep I'll give it a go, thank you.

I used to use a cheap mascara from rimmel in purple tube, I think it was called false lash effect clump something. They stopped making it. It was fab. it's so annoying to find a product that works only for it to be discontinued.

I've just noticed HotSince82 the benefit roller one. I've seen it recommended quite a lot. I've never tried any of their products. I've been put off by their packaging......which sounds silly I know, plus I've never been able to get the attention of the sales assistants to ask questions...... I think I'm too old

I’d second the soap and glory thick and fast. The name is misleading- it’s not thickening imo.
I received it in a gift set at Christmas and was dubious as I usually go higher end but I’m really impressed.
I used to use Clinique doll eyes which was perfect for this but it’s long discontinued, sadly.

I’ve also used roller lash and liked it.

I have thick black lashes and really rate tubing mascaras; blinc and Clinique Power Lash are my favourites with Clinique being the one I prefer. The added bonus is they don't smudge or flake and are so easy to remove.

Eyeko black magic gives lots of length without any volume. Much to my annoyance as I wanted the volume.

You can get a travel size for a tenner to try out. Bought mine in selfridges beauty hall but available online too.

YSL no other mascara compares. It lasts and doesn’t smudge. I have naturally long lashes but like the effect

Benefit I found it snapped my lashes and was a pain in the arse to remove

Another vote for S&G here. Not thick or clumpy at all and it adds a nice length.

L’Oréal telescopic (the one in good or black tune). I’ve tried loads over the years (I’m 40) but have stuck to this for the last 5-6 years.

It’s about £10.

Gold or black tube (not good or black tune!,)

Ooh I totally agree that Roller Lash while good, does absolutely snap lashes. I love Eyeko, and Ysl too . Beauty bay often sell travel size mascaras which are great .

Just tried soap and glory thick and fast, not a patch on roller lash and smudges terribly.

Will try telescopic next x

I agree with the telescopic only one I'm not allergic too and the brush is so easy to use if you are hamfisted and shortsighted like me!!!

I used Clinique Naturally Glossy for years which did exactly that - lengthen and define. I might go back to it actually - I can't even remember why I stopped using it!

Glossier Lash Slick

Google '100 mascaras one eye'

I use a waterproof one by Essence called all eyes on me, £2 from wilko and honestly one of the best mascaras I've ever used and I've tried a LOT over the years. It lengthens my lashes without clumping and doesn't smudge (on me anyway)

The best mascara I ever had was from Aldi and it was a 3D one and was amazing for lengthening lashes. Don't think they stock it anymore though Wilkos Essence Lash Princess is quite good and really cheap.

Second Estée Lauder double wear. Lengthens without too much volume, stays on all day and is very easy to take off.