Dupe for Bobbi Brown eyeshadow pencils

[Ohyesiam]

I had my make up done at Bobbi Brown today, which was free and enjoyable. I went on to spend a fortune on products ( 15% of first orders online) , but drew the line at the two eye shadow pencils as they are over £20 each.
Has anyone tried and liked any cheaper brands? I’ve only used powder eyeshadow before, but there’s are chunky and the creamy eyeshadow really stays put.

Looking forward to any suggestions.

Laura Mercier makes some too, but they may be a similar price.

Kiko have some and they are good too.

M&S have some as well, and their Rosie collection also have a few. The Rosie ones are IMO better than the regular ones.

Kiko have a good range of colours, elf ones are quite nice too

Usually get no7 which are good but recently noticed that H&M did them too-haven’t tried though

Thanks, some brands that I wouldn’t have thought of so will check them out.

Beauty Pie? They look remarkably similar. It's not a product I use myself, but I have bought other makeup items from Beauty Pie and been really pleased with them. I am generally very much a high end beauty shopper.

The Beauty Pie ones are great and I think actually better than the BB ones, although the colours are a bit limited.

iirc the Laura Mercier ones are more expensive than Bobbi Brown but they are fab.