My DH has never worn either because of a longstanding issue with his sense of smell, which has been resolved this year. I'd like to buy him some for Christmas. He has a beard, so it'll be cologne rather than a true aftershave.
I have no idea where to begin. Happy to spend reasonable ££ on it. He is in his early 40s, tall, dark, bearded, looks like a cyclist, mostly wears checked shirts and jeans.