which of these boots please

[thefootofourstairs]

to wear with a black dress to a 'do' ?
www.sezane.com/en/product/winter-collection/johanna-boots?cou_Id=2869

www.sezane.com/en/product/winter-collection/high-sara-boots?cou_Id=2586

Both nice but I think I prefer the Sara ones.

The first ones, they are more simple and classic, can’t see them going out of style whereas the block heel might? Also not so keen on the big buckle on the second pair.

one vote for each then !

Sara, they're lovely - the others look a little dated, IMHO.

Johanna definitely, I think they're miles nicer. I'm not keen on block heels or the croc pattern.

Sara, I've got similar in green

Either would be lovely. Can't see either going out if style quickly. I think Sara. Ishtar be more comfortable because of the block heel

yougotanology thats what i was thinking with the johanna ones , had some similar a looong time ago . i did like them alot though.

Johanna here

I like the first ones. Both nice but I prefer the first ones.

Johanna for me.