Which of these shoes would you buy?

[Nikhedonia]

Fed up of wearing heels to work and want to wear some stylish flats.

Which of these would you choose?

My current favourites are the patent ones, but I'm a bit worried they will get scuffed

Brewster for me

I have the patent ones and am still attempting to break them in after 3 years. They’re fine for work in my current job as I drive but caused some serious blisters when I commuted on the train and had to walk to the station. No scuffing issues though! Personally I’d pick the 3rd ones.

3rd ones too.... im on my 3rd pair of Chesters as they go with absolutely everything and are so comfy. First 2 pairs fit like a dream, 3rd pair is patent and yes, they are a nightmare to break in! (No blisters, just that feeling they are half a size too small , and arent softening in the same way the plain leather ones do).

Brewsters are really nice.

@Expressedways eek, 3 years?!

I like the third ones, but they already look a bit worn in

Like above poster I had the shiny version, gave up after a few years and gave them to my Mum. I loved them but they were never going to break in and be comfortable ☹️

They are all nice but you really don't have to pay that much for a pair of loafers just as good as those. Have you tried Dune?

In fairness they haven’t had that much wear in 3 years because they are so stiff anywhere with much walking involved is automatically out. They are still in my desk drawer at work from last winter as I used to commute in snow boots. I’d actually forgotten I even had them until this post popped up
I have made a resolution to take them home tonight and wear them round the house until they give as I really do love them. So thank you for that! But if I was buying again I’d definitely go non patent.

I'd go for the Brewster. once you lose a tassle on the other pairs they'll be unwearable, I reckon.

M&S are selling a very similiar pair for £45