Between Clinique chubby stick in curvaceous coal and Sainsbury's boutique waterproof eye pencil in charcoal ,well nothing apart from the price Clinique is £18.00 and sainsbury £2.25 oh and btw the Sainsbury's one is easier to apply, I use it a kind of kohl liner and also along the top lash line ,plus as it's waterproof it's great for holidays ,enjoy I'm going to get the gold one next