Any good new tubing mascaras?

[Lotsofsausage]

I have a real issue with Mascara - hooded eyes and oily skin means to smudges really bad - waterproof ones are worse as they still smudge but then it doesn't easily wipe off when I'm out and about!
Tubing mascara is best for me, I've tried a few:
-NYX - ok but does not give me the volume I need, also starts to clump when it's been opened.

• Estee Lauder double wear - still smudges by the end of the day!
• Loreal Beauty tubes (the red and white one with the primer and black ends) - this is the best so far, volume and staying power wise - but I find it hard to apply and get spider lashes from it.

Any other suggestions? Any of the other loreal ones tubing?

SlipperOrchid yes, Trish is definitely tubing.

You can get it in Selfridges, Harvey Nicholl's or Liberty. These stores also deliver online.

I bought the Maybelline Snapscara one from Sainsbury’s on special offer so super cheap, having read about it on this thread.
It’s amazing! As has been said before, doesn’t seem to come off in tubes, but acts like tubing mascara. I wore it to the gym, in the pool, sauna and steam room and all day for two days, and it didn’t budge an inch. I’m converted and will be stocking up.

After following this thread, I have bought Clinique Lash Power and I'm loving it. So much nicer than No7 Stay Perfect! Will try Trish McEvoy next time.