Which of these 2 jackets go best?

[macnab]

I bought this jumpsuit to wear to an upcoming event. Part of it takes place in a church (it's not a wedding) sonid like a jacket to cover up a bit and also not certain the weather will behave. I don't want to spend a lot on the jacket. Please tell me which of these two would work best. I like them both but can't get near a shop to try on so was hoping to just buy one online and be done with it!

Second one

Second one

I much prefer the first one.

The first one as the second is quite boxy and you would lose your waist

Second

First one

oh no I was hoping for a bigger majority! shades of brexit
I think I'll give it a bit longer to see if any more 'votes' come in

Defo the first, second will make your outfit more casual than what it is.

Hmm, it's tough without seeing it as an outfit but my preference is 1 I think. The alternative is to go for a more oversized blazer type thing?

Second one.
First one looks a bit dated. Beautiful play suit!

First one

I think the second one. The first one feels a bit too 'sharp' for the jumpsuit. I think the feel of the outfit is softer, as is the second jacket.

First one definitely

Definitely second, the first is very dated.

Definitely first one. As a pp said the second one is more boxy, you need the nipped in waist of the first one

I prefer the first one but I think the second one might go better. Can you buy both and return one?

Neither?! The second one runs the risk of making you look really boxy, the first one I like the shape of the body but not the sleeves. I agree a white jacket is the way to go over what is a stunning jumpsuit but I don’t think either of those are quite right (sorry). But maybe they’ll be better in person? But both and try them on?

Second. The first reminds me of something a circus ringmaster would wear.

The first one looks so old fashioned. Definitely the second one.

Ok I've gone with the second one, only because when I looked at similar jumpsuits on the PhaseEight website they were styled with that sort of jacket. May last year was incredibly warm so maybe it will be the same this year and I'll literally only have it on for an hour so it won't really matter!

First one

I think the first is very dated. The jumpsuit gives the effect of high waist trousers therefore I think a cropped jacket might finish at the wrong point to be flattering - you don’t want the bottom of the blazer to finish parallel with the high waistline. Hard to say without seeing them on. Failing that, a longline white blazer would also look nice imo.

First one

Right so, I'll wait for the second one to arrive and try it on (might post a pic here if I'm brave enough!) and if it's not right I'll return and order the first one! God I really wish I had my own personal stylist I find this sort of thing so hard

While I'm at it, would anyone care to suggest accessories for this outfit?! I have nude patent high heels, gold leather wedges or silvery-sparkly peep toe high heel (small platform sole) shoes. Would any of those work? please say yes so I don't have to do more shopping What type of jewelry? Just earrings? Big/dangly ones??