Please help me find green eye shadow

[doubtingdaisy]

I'm looking for a moss green eye shadow.......not the bright green ones that are everywhere. A sludgy green colour! I have one that's nearly finished and it's so old the writing has disappeared from the container and I just can't find it anywhere.

I have a Mac eyeliner that is moss green which is creamy so I smoosh it over my eye line/lid and sort of create an eyeshadow? Would that do? Or just look at Mac as they do all sorts of colours

Urban Decay eyeshadow single in Mildew

Stila do a really nice one khaki one if you like the more shiny look. I love their eyeshadows.

I love my Estee Lauder duo - mossy green with a beigey gold. I've had it a while and the writing has faded too, but I think it's called khaki. The green really flatters my greenish/gold eyes and the shadow stays put all day. I use a fat brush for the eye socket and a fine brush to 'paint' a line under the eye.

mac

NYX - Zen

I've got that NYX one - it's nice.

Urban Decay Mildew is a lovely, sludgy green. I really like it.

I've got a good Benefit one & Liz Earle do a good one. Could be worth trying Kiko too.

Could you show a picture of the one you have that's nearly gone? Then we can find a good match

I have this one (in ‘Herb’) and really like it www.glossier.com/products/lidstar

Mac sumptuous olive is gorgeous (photo from google!)

www.cultbeauty.co.uk/lime-crime-venus-xl-ii.html The LimeCrime Venus XL II palette has a couple of lovely earthy mossy green shades (and is just gorgeous all-round)

NYX sell a matte moss green shade in 'Stoked' £2.50 - otherwise, Origins, available at Boots have a selection of matte green in a number of different shades

Had a mac one years ago like that. I miss it now!!!

Charlotte Tilbury has a lovely green eyeshadow pencil thing that is so easy to use and is a fab colour and stays on forever www.charlottetilbury.com/uk/colour-chameleon-smoky-emerald.html

Thanks so much. Great suggestions.

I've got the Nyx one and also a Mac one and tbh disappointingly I've found the Nyx one much better in terms of not being so 'powdery'. I love the some of the Mac colours, but can't justify the price tag.

OP you just need Bobbi Brown I think it's actually called Moss it's a sludgey Matt green and not at all bright or shimmery.

Here it is. Many of your suggestions are very very similar.

Why is nice green shadow so hard to get? I have green eyes and, contrary to what the experts say, I prefer green to mauve.

NYX has excellent shadows, as others have said.