Opinions on these boots please?

[Badtasteflump]

These arrived today and I can’t decide - partly because they’re a bit higher than I would normally wear. I want some going out boots to wear with skinnies and a naice top or a short dress and opaques. What do you think?

I usually wear quite mum-ish and boring boots I think, so wanted to try something different - be as brutal as u like!

Boots

Well they have been returned this morning so message well and truly received!

I've ordered some other ones which I'm slightly scared to link to because I want to like them - these

They won't be for 'going out' - I'm going to try and find some black kitten heels ones in my size for that - but I do want some tan boots for every day stuff....

Do say if they're hideous - I could always return them (again!)

I think either of the brown/tan ones are fine as everyday boots.

I also think they are fine for everyday boots and are very similar to the first pair.

I much prefer the 2nd pair of brown boots that you’ve ordered for everyday wear in comparison to the first

The second pair you've ordered aren't to different to the first pair really. They're both a bit too sensible and 'Mumsy' for me I'm afraid, and neither are going out boots. Sorry.

Nothing wrong with mum and sensible if you like them, I think you have similar taste to me and I'm both a mum and sensible, and need comfy shoes.