Liquid or gel eyeliner in brown?

[Amortentia]

I’ve been using a gel pencil in my waterline but I can’t seem to get a good enough line across my eyelid. So, I think I might give a liquid or gel applied with a brush a try.

I am very pale with green eyes so would be grateful for any recommendations. I think black would be too harsh and find lots of browns have too much of a red tone. Anyone use a brown without red in it or would suggest another colour I should try?

Try the Bobbi Brown one, they also do a fine brush as well. The gel liner comes in a small pot, very easy to apply and stays on.

Maybelline do a brown eyeliner ‘felt pen’ and also a gel with a brush.

I like the Beauty Pie one - very dark chocolate brown. Stays on very well. I tried Mac, Bobbi Brown, Laura Mercier but they all gave me panda eyes

Thanks for the suggestions, I haven’t heard of Beaty pie before but I’ll give it a look.