Tubing mascaras are the only ones which don't smudge under my eyes. I was using Clinique Full to Flutter, it was perfect but they've discontinued it, so I'm after a replacement. I've tried these in the past but wondered if there was anything better:
Clinique High Impact Curling: the only thing I didn't like about it was the curved brush
Clinique Lash Power: not volumising enough
Estee Lauder Doublewear: They've discontinued the volumising version, but I found all the doublewear ones to be scratchy
DHC: this would be perfect if it was more volumising
Blinc: went flakey very quickly
Revlon Multiplier: not bad for a budget buy but dried out and therefore went flakey quickly.
I know I could use a primer to add volume but I don't want to because I'm lazy and I don't like having loads of products.
Do you have a tubing mascara which also volumises that you can recommend (non-tubing mascaras need not apply)!