These shoes - yay or nay?

[Rockyhighway]

Funnily enough there’s a link to a smiliar shoe further down the page. Anyway these - it’s colour more than style which I’d like opinions on please.

Thanks

I like them, I’ve been looking at a similar pair but haven’t bought them as yet

I like them a lot and think they'll be a very versatile summer/autumn shoe.

Wish I could wear loafers, but anything without a strap flies off my feet

Thanks .... have tried on and like them a lot - love the colour but was worried it is a bit grannyish ... can’t be as there are loads if shoes in similar colour in shops atm.

I like those. A lot.

I wear loafers, and find them very versatile, but for Carvela I think they are expensive, and a bit bland sorry and hate the colour of the ''snaffles''..

If you had put them up and not said which brand/price I would of said Clarks at half the cost.

But if you like them why not!

Something about the height and shape of the upper looks a bit granny to me. I think guilt from dune at the best loafers on the high street right now, close in shape and style to Gucci!

Are not at!

My mother would like those.

Funnily enough, I've recently bought a Dune pair, mine are fair more Blush colour in real life!

They’re okay. I agree they do look very Clark’s-ish, which isn’t a bad thing but I wouldn’t pay £109 for them. Or any shoes actually. But then I’m a penny pincher!

I tried those Dune shoes on Buster, they are lovely but too narrow for my feet. Have to shop with a bunion in mind! Despite the mixed reviews, I probably will keep them as they are really comfortable. Mad, I might not be far off your Mum’s age 😂

The dune ones are narrow. I have narrow feet and had to size up. So the Debenhams ones probably better!

It a nay from me. Especially If your planning on wearing them with tan stockings and a midi floral skirt unless your over 80. They are very grannyish sorry

My mum has some like that. She’s 80.

Ouch. No tan stockings and floral skirts and a long way off my 80th.

Nay from me, granyish.

Very Gucci

If you are a size 3, what about these? I have them in another colour and they are really comfortable.
www.tkmaxx.com/uk/en/women/shoes/flats/sand-suede-pointed-penny-loafers/p/25621029

I have to admit my Dune ones really need some breaking in!