Non-smudging brown-black mascara

[ElizabethinherGermanGarden]

Can anyone recommend a really good one? I like Estée Lauder Zero Smudge lengthening mascara for black but they don't make brown anymore. I look better with brown until it all melts and goes all over my face, which is what's happening with my No.7 waterproof brown.

Suggestions gratefully received.

Benefit "they're real" is great. It doesn't move all day. In fact, is hard to take off. I use the black one but I'm pretty sure there is a brown version.

Ah, thanks. My sister uses the black one so I might borrow hers to see how it lasts on me before shelling out cash.

I wear the Benefit They're Real in Beyond Brown and it lasts forever.