Protected Species coats (other than the Mac)

[Laquila]

I have the Mac which is bloody brilliantly, and I’m now thinking of getting one of the others as a casual rainproof jacket - is the Commuter more flattering than it looks?! I like the shorter one but IME, short rain jackets leave you a bit exposed. I’m a fan of parkas generally, but I’m not sure about their Parka style - any recommendations?

laquila, I bought the commuter, but sent it back because it wasn’t flattering on me - it made me look huge, and I don’t think going down a size would have helped. I swapped it for the parka, which looked much better on me.

I’ve got the parka and it’s a great cut. I regret buying the grey colour as I look washed out and wish I’d held out for the khaki.

I do like the khaki. Does anyone have the City Walker?