Which Ash starry trainer?

[polyhymnia]

I've ordered these two pairs of trainers in the Ash sale, fully intending to send one back.

www.ashfootwear.co.uk/women-c1/ash-majestic-star-motif-trainers-silver-emerald-green-leather-p2452
www.ashfootwear.co.uk/women-c1/ash-majestic-bis-star-trainers-black-vinyl-leather-leopard-print-p2453

Trouble is, I really like both of them and just can't make up my mind. And can't really afford both.
Can anyone help me with views please? I expect some people may not like the style at all but I definitely do!

I'm one of those who doesn't like them but willing to help! I prefer the black as they'd go with more outfits, especially in winter. The silver ones are more spring/summer to me, do you think there'll be any left in a couple of months?

I like them but prefer the first ones. Not overly keen on the second ones [black ones].

I really like these too:

hush

hush
The second pair are out of stock but you could try John Lewis [online] as they do hush things.

Next also do a pair but think they are not leather

www.next.co.uk/g22318s10#152212

www.next.co.uk/g22318s3#176950

www.next.co.uk/g22318s5#445833

www.next.co.uk/g22318s4#718806

Maybe you could buy the white ash ones and a pair of the cheaper dark next ones?

I really don’t like the first pair, they look like kids trainers, second pair for me.

They are not to my taste. My daughter who is 9 would love the silver ones .

Love them

Have white ones with silver stars, which I wear in.summer. so comfy, buttery leather.

In your case.... hmmm, I like the silver ones best, but the black ones you could wear with opaque tights!

These are £50 something on Brandalley currently in both colours. PM me if you want me to recommend you as a friend for a £20 OFF your first £80+ spend. Get both!

PS. I know you asked for opinions but pfttt life's too short to be a dull miserable git (at 38 I have the light up Irregular Choice influx trainers - hideous but love them to bits!).

Barefoot I’ve PM’d you if that’s ok.

Done it Theconifers25 anyone else?!

Thanks

I like the silver ones.

I liked the silver until I saw the black,but how much? My timberlands were only £30

I have these ones, sadly not for the sale price!

www.ashfootwear.co.uk/sale-c6/ash-majestic-star-motif-trainers-white-leather-silver-accent-p2393

Really love them now but they were horribly hard on my heels for quite a few wears. Once broken in they’re really comfy.

Thanks so much for comments. Still dithering. Many thanks for offer, barefoot. Not sure how to pm people but will check up on MN site.