Liquid eye liner pencil

[HintBean]

Hi,

I'm looking for a liquid eyeliner pencil in black? Any recommendations?

I've come across this Charlotte Tilbury one but the reviews are mixed

m.johnlewis.com/charlotte-tilbury-rock-'n'-kohl-liquid-eyeliner-pencil/p2127514

I read about the cat Von d one on one of these threads. It’s pretty good. It stays in place all day and has a lovely fine tip.

I use the smashbox pen it's vv good lasts ages and easy to use