Tubing mascaras - alternative to Clinique Lash Power

[Timefortea99]

Anybody who has used Lash Power in the past - have you moved on to another brand, and if so, what brand and how is it?

Before Lash Power I did not use mascara because it used to smudge almost immediately. Lash Power is great for staying put and was a revelation to me. But recently I think I would prefer a mascara with a bit more oomph but still a tubing one as they seem to be best for not budging. Any recommendations or is Lash Power the best? I have used the other Clinique tubing one but did not like it - think it is a version of Lash Power with extra fanning or flutterbility.

I'm not sure about tubing but Estée Lauder double wear mascara with the gold lid does not smudge at all.

I wear contact lenses and have very watery eyes even when wearing sunglasses, and this never runs or smudges.

Another vote for No7 in the gold tube. It doesn't make my lashes especially thick or long BUT it doesn't smudge and I'll settle for that over the panda look any day

No 7 gold tube here too

If you want more oomph you won't get it from the no 7 gold tube one. It's more an understated daytime mascara in my experience. Best tubing mascara for extra oomph is L'Oréal double extension. Really good product, gives really big lashes but doesn't clump.

Yep, l'oreal Double extension is ace, no clumps and stays put all day.

Double wear is my go to. No smudging. Tubing as far as I'm aware.

Is the new Dior mascara 'Pump&Volume' a tubing mascara?

Dior one like a tooth paste or benefit false lash one in the silvery blue tube.
I used to use the gold Estée Lauder one but found it went in the creases under my eyes ?

Bobbi Brown Intensifying long wear is good but just moved back to Estée Lauder Double Wear and think it's the best tubing one, definitely better than the Clinique Flutter to full one I've just finished (though harder to wash off).