Please help me pick a skirt!

[wherehasthesummergone]

I've bought two skirts but can only keep one - except I can't decide which one. Not sure what I'd wear it for, probably going out with friends or a meal to celebrate a family event. What would I wear it with?

I like the first, floaty one. Where's it from?

They both like great but I marginally prefer skirt a.
Are you sure you can't keep both

Keep the first one.

First one.

First one.

I like the second one best, but it would depend on the placement of the roses on the back (if any).

Which one goes best with tops etc that you already own?

I'd keep whichever one you can get 3-4 outfits out of, without having to buy anything new. If you can't make up a couple of outfits with your pre-existing wardrobe, then are either worth keeping?

First one looks loads comfier and can be dressed up or down.

Both are nice, I don't know your age, but the first looks a bit frumpy to me ,or it could do depending on the top it is paired with- it would be pretty with a strappy black top. I prefer the second one partly because I think it could go with more covered up but tighter tops, but I do tend to prefer tighter clothes if you have a great figure, which you do, but that's a personal preference thing.

I agree the first one is frumpy looking IMO. But it's a matter of taste of course.

I like both and they both suit you. They are very different too, so if you could possibly afford both, I'd be tempted to keep both!

And the first doesn't look 'frumpy' at all - it's lovely and goes really nicely with those shoes.

Thank you for your help, sounds like the overall consensus is the first one! I feel most comfortable in it too. My wardrobe in general needs a revamp so I'd need to buy a top to go with either skirt, what would be best? I was thinking a black one like summer suggested. What could I wear to cover up though, in case I'm cold.

Fruitcocktail They're both from Oasis.

Biker jacket or denim jacket? You'd be taking it off indoors anyway, so it doesn't really matter. The skirt would also look nice with a black turtle neck and ankle boots when the weather is cooler too.

They both look great on you, but first one for me too. I'd get bored of the second one faster, and I'd fear it would date sooner.