Another Budget Mascara Question - Collection Mascaras

[MinesaPinot]

I was looking at the Collection mascaras in Boots this morning - has anyone tried them and can recommend one in particular? My usual mascara is They're Real, but I'm finding it difficult to justify the price, and it's getting hard to remove just lately (I don't know whether they've changed the formula).

Any other budget recommendations?

I recommend Boots Natural Collection actually. Water Guard and Lash Build are both good and they're about £2.50.

I second that recommendation for the Natural Collection mascaras. They don't flake or leave me with panda eyes.

Also natural collection, I don't wear make up very often but grabbed this for an event the other day and it's brilliant for the price.

No clogged up clumpy brush and had it on overnight and still no panda eyes.

The ones at Wilcos. Loads of them. I love the red and yellow waterproof one.

Great, thanks everyone.