Recommend waterproof mascara that works....

[cessie322]

I have oily eyelids which I've managed to sort out with the urban decay primer. However I cannot seem to find a waterproof mascara that will stay put. I've used expensive and cheaper ones to no avail, they all seem to give me panda eyes. Any suggestions please?

max factor aqua lash- survives swimming with a 3yo!

Bobbi Brown No Smudge mascara - I have hooded eyes (skin pretty much rests on my eyelashes and so rubs any mascara off - sounds delightful, I realise) and never found a mascara that stay put before this one. It can still sometimes be a tiny bit smudgy by the end of a long day if I've been rubbing my eyes a lot, but for the most part it's brilliant.

Maybelline The Falsies. Doesn't budge if you cry, swim or have a shower! Comes off at the end of the day with Vaseline.

Boots No7 stay perfect .
Amazing .Here

Thanks everyone, I haven't tried any of those. I did try another number 7 one, a red container which didn't work so not sure that the stay perfect would but I can try. Will give them a go starting with the cheapest! Hopefully one will finally work.

Double wear, the tubing one. Doesn't budge no matter what.

Schnitzel would that be the zero smudge one? Googling it here.

That's the one!

No7 is cheap and does stay in place

No7 Extreme Length Waterproof Mascara (the purple tube). You will need a good makeup remover to get it off -- the oilier kind.

Autograph waterproof, usually get panda eyes but this stayed put ecen through my Mum's funeral

Thanks everyone, will check them all out. I've loads to try now!