Yes or no to these shoes?

[Jungfraujoch]

Sorry it's M & S 😄 I was thinking with a cropped or wide leg trouser?

It's a no from me

No from me too I'm afraid

Don't mind them actually

No. They're horrible.

Not even with TWO trousers :)

Not sure what th they're trying to be. May I suggest a clarks hamble oak? If I plug them enough I might get a freebie. And I love them.

Brogue trainer? Yuck.

Not bad. Clarks Hamble Oaks are fab

Euw. Not for me 😕

No. But if you like them it doesn't matter what anyone else thinks.

No.

Not keen!

Another fan of the Hamble Oak so would go with them or a pair of Stan Smiths (or similar).

nope

its the white sole thats wrong

No from me. There is no place in the world for a trogue.

I don't think that trainer brogues are always wrong, I love these for example. However I think the m&s ones aren't quite there, not fashionable enough, a bit too footglove

MIL might wear them with her Damart.

Theyre OK.

If you watch a few videos of trinny London on YouTube (she of trinny and susannah previous fame) you will see the wide leg shorter trouser combined with the type of shoe you've chosen OP. It seems this is her current go to uniform. To be honest I think you need to be fairly slim and gamine (Is that a word?) to pull it off but it could look good.

You've all pretty much sad what I was thinking!

Frumpy I'm afraid!

I don't think they look like a stylish version of trainer brogues, I would keep looking.

No here too. If you really want a trainer brogue cross-breed you can find better elsewhere. The M&S ones have completely missed the mark.

Thanks for the 'no's!

I quite like Fuzzypegs ones but not in a metallic.