Quick Poll - Yay or Nay to this AllSaints jacket

[ChopOrNot]

The 20% code off has beguiled me into ordering a leather jacket (NOVEMBER is the code if it helps). So it is here. I love it. And then I see the photos I just took of it and get all hyper-critical on it myself

So - yay? or nay?

(Excuse odd lighting - just wanted a done up/undone photo)

I say yes but I think it deserve a bit more of a dressy outfit to make it look the part.

Yes but doesn't look its best with that top because of the neck

I'm thinking a patterned shirt with black skinny jeans.

Or a plain floaty shirt.

Hmmm. More jeans and jumper kind of person than floaty shirts.

I like the jacket although It doesn't really go with the outfit you are wearing in the picture though sorry.

Yes, definitely, but not with that top, partly because of the v-neck, and partly because it's too long.

Not sure that jeans and jumper sort of outfits would be a bad thing, unless you think that most of your tops are going to be too long relative to the jacket?

Looks good. Your whole look looks good (hair etc). wear it your way.
Does look better undone though.

I have that one (the Bales) they do it every year, but this year it's particularly good, the leather is much better. I like that it's less of an obvious biker style, much more classic and long lasting. A lot of the current AS range are very trend led and will date quickly.

I think it suits you but don't do it up. Although only zipped a little bit like you've done isn't that bad, I just think done up looks more like you're wearing it to actually get on a motorbike rather than wearing for style!

I have the same one and love it. I normally wear it with a long sleeved t shirt, jeans and trainers or boots. Looks good!

Also your top will always be longer than the jacket since it's waist length so I wouldn't worry about that too much.

Jacket - yes.

With jeans and jumper - no.

I like it and I think it looks great on you though better unfastened as people have said. The longer top underneath looks fine too - in fact I thought that was kind of the point.

As for not wearing them with jumpers....