Smokey eye pen

[Norky1975]

I have the smokey eye pen from pixi, the effect it gives is amazing! But it's running out and they don't do it anymore - I've tried other imitations but nothing gives me the same results! Pixi recommended I try another product of theirs but it's pricey. Has anyone got any suggestions?

The Elizabeth Arden smokey eye pencil possibly? I'm not familiar with the pixi pen so not sure how comparable they are though.

look on ebay:
These are great :)

Not used the Pixi pen, but I really like this for a smoky lash line, lasts well combined with the Urban Decay primer potion.

Do you mean the lid and line in the dark blue tube? Love them and picked up a few on amazon cheaply.