Help me pick

[NantucketNightbird]

I'm very torn, the brown are replay and very cheap. Which do you all prefer?

Definitely the first ones, they'd go with more stuff too.

The grey?

It depends entirely on your style.

I'd go with the brown ones myself, they'd work with a few things I like to wear, whereas the grey ones would look dreadful with most things I own. I've plenty of friends who'd choose the grey over the brown though. Also, grey suede wouldn't last 5 minutes on me.

I can see a beige and a brown. I prefer the brown but the beige ones are smarter. They are both nice, depends what you need them for - work or casual?

yy, the first ones look more beige than grey on my screen too. The op said grey though so I'm guessing that's what they are.

I guess they do look more beige I'm a sahm, usually style is a little bit hippy, I usually wear my velvet floral docs. Dresses/skirts with thick tights and cardigans or knit jumpers. I'm 31

If the brown are very cheap, get both?

I'd get the first pair if I had to pick but your style sounds more like the second.

Yes I'm going for the brown I don't think the others would go with as much of my wardrobe, thanks

Good choice! Now could you post a link as I'm rather liking the brown ones for me

I'm no good at links but they are 39.99 on tkmaxx, also have them in pewter on there

Thanks!

yy, the brown ones sound like the right choice in that case.

Oh! They are fantastic in pewter. Would go with more stuff than brown too. Get the pewter replay ones

I've ordered the brown... But the pewter are nice and my foot is generally a 3 I may have to have them (plus the two come to near enough the price of the grey/beige)

Both would be perfect, well, assuming they're comfortable.