I have found 2 mascaras that don't smudge on me

[Aquamarine70]

I have eyelash extensions do just wear mascara on t bottom lashes. I don't have oily or watery eyes & find that most mascaras cheap, waterproof & high end just smudge or flake. I was in Mecca Maxima shop & they let me try Urbsn Decay Cannon ball & Too Faced Lash Injection. I had no smudging. The Too Faced had a gooey texture but it was ok to remove. I'm not sure if if will go sticky or clumpy after a few uses.The Cannon ball came off ok with Simple eye make up remover. I am so pleased to have finally found mascara that doesn't smudge.

Ooh - do they do it in brown?
My mascara always smudges so have to wear waterproof, but can only ever find it in black

They only come in black only. I'm so happy that I have found one that works.
Have you tried Loreal Voluminous waterproof? That may come in brown. I have read good reviews on that one.