Non clumpy/flaky mascara that's not tubing

[Camembertie]

I really need some new black mascara, I see to pull out my lashes so have sparse but long lashes.

I would like a natural looking mascara that's going to stay put all day, but am wary of tubing as think action of removing might cause more lashes to come out :(

Can go to shops later, House of Fraser, Boots etc, what do you recommend?

Ta

^used

Max Factor Masterpiece is brilliant, it has a really good thin wand, and I've never had a problem with clumping or flaking. I've been using it for years and every time I try a different type I always end up going back to this one.

Lancôme Hypnose. It's the only one I use now as it does exactly what I want. Looks natural, not clumpy and stays put. Thoroughly recommend.

No 7 intense volume, I buy it again and again.

Maybe line illegal definition

Removing tubing mascara is far more gentle than any other mascara, all it requires is a bit of warm water (I use a flannel) to loosen and then simply wipe away so I don't really know where that perception comes from. I'd avoid waterproof mascara for sturdy removal but not tubing.

Anyhow, a non tubing mascara that doesn't flake and clump that I like is the Inimitable Intense by Chanel. Remove gently with a bi-phase or micellar water, it doesn't respond as well to standard makeup removers.