which eyeliner do you use for tightlining?

[DiscoDancer]

And doesn't budge and is contact lens friendly? And waterproof obvs!

The clarins 3 pronged one.

http://m.clarins.co.uk/3-dot-liner/C050204015.html?cgid=625&dwvarC0502040155_color=01%20intense%20black&start=1

This one? Does it budge at all? I want something that stays put all day

laura mercier powder eyeliner in navy with a v small brush. done right it is amazing and doesn't budge - might have to check you don't have a tiny bit in the inner corners of eyes right after doing it, bleurgh, but after that yep, will stay all day. They'll do it for you at a counter if you want to try it, I had mine done years ago in selfridges and have been convert ever since.

that said, if anyone suggests a pencil that is more effective, bring it on!

Yep, that one. Doesn't budge on me. Don't put it on waterline though, otherwise it will run.

How do you actually do it? I thought it was on the waterline,is it not?

I've been using a pencil on the water line too....

Under eye it's ok. Upper is not nice.